On a crisp autumn morning in the rolling hills of Tuscany, Marchese Nicolò Incisa della Rocchetta surveys the vineyards of Tenuta San Guido, home to the legendary Sassicaia wine. The vines stretch out before him, heavy with Cabernet Sauvignon grapes nearly ready for harvest. A gentle breeze carries the earthy scent of sun-warmed soil and ripening fruit.
It's a scene that would have been unthinkable just a few decades ago in a region dominated by Sangiovese and strictly regulated wine classifications.
"My father was considered mad for planting Cabernet here in the 1940s," Nicolò says with a wry smile, his weathered hands caressing a cluster of deep purple grapes. "Now Sassicaia is one of the most sought-after wines in the world."
Indeed, Sassicaia and its fellow Super Tuscans - Tignanello, Ornellaia, Masseto, Solaia - have become coveted trophies for wine collectors and investors, fetching astronomical prices at auction and featuring prominently in the cellars of the world's top restaurants and wine enthusiasts. But how did these upstart wines, initially classified as mere "table wines," come to revolutionize the Italian wine industry and reshape the global fine wine market?
To understand the Super Tuscan phenomenon, we must rewind to the 1970s, when Tuscany's wine industry was mired in mediocrity and outdated traditions. The region's most famous wine, Chianti, had become synonymous with cheap plonk in straw-covered fiaschi bottles adorning checkered tablecloths in tourist trap restaurants.
Enter a group of visionary winemakers who dared to break the rules. They planted international grape varieties like Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. They adopted modern winemaking techniques. And most importantly, they focused fanatically on quality over quantity.
It was a complete paradigm shift, these producers were thinking like the top châteaux of Bordeaux, not like traditional Italian winemakers. They were aiming for greatness, not just drinkability.
The results were extraordinary. Wines like Tignanello (first vintage 1971) and Sassicaia (first commercial release 1968) began turning heads among critics and collectors. By the 1980s, they were commanding prices on par with top Bordeaux and Burgundy, wines that had dominated the fine wine market for decades.
But success bred imitators, and soon the term "Super Tuscan" was being applied to any number of ambitious new wines from the region. The wine world found itself grappling with fundamental questions: What exactly defines a Super Tuscan? And are these wines truly worth their often eye-watering price tags?
What emerged was a complex picture of innovation, marketing savvy, and the fickle nature of wine fashion. But at the core was an undeniable truth: the best Super Tuscans represent a remarkable achievement in winemaking.
Take Sassicaia, the original Super Tuscan. Many sommeliers consistently ranked recent vintages of Sassicaia alongside - and often above - comparable First Growth Bordeaux (the most prestigious and expensive classification of Bordeaux wines) selling for two or three times the price.
The quality is undeniable, but what's really impressive is the consistency across vintages. These wines are built to last decades, evolving beautifully in the cellar.
Indeed, older vintages of top Super Tuscans have become some of the most prized bottles in the wine world. A single bottle of Sassicaia 1985 sold recently for over $10,000 at auction. Masseto, the 100% Merlot masterpiece from Bolgheri, regularly fetches $1,000+ per bottle on release, with prices for mature vintages climbing even higher.
But the success of Super Tuscans has had impacts far beyond the rarefied world of wine collecting. It fundamentally transformed the economy and culture of Tuscany, a region previously known more for its rolling hills and Renaissance art than its fine wines.
Before Super Tuscans, being a winemaker in Tuscany was not a prestigious job, but now top winemakers are celebrities. Young people want to study enology and work in wine. It's brought a whole new energy to the region.
The influx of money and talent has lifted quality across the board. Even traditional wines like Brunello di Montalcino and Chianti Classico have seen a renaissance, adopting more modern winemaking techniques while maintaining their historic character.
Not everyone is thrilled with these changes, however. Some critics argue that the success of Super Tuscans has led to a homo-genization of Tuscan wine, with too many producers chasing international palates at the expense of local traditions.
"We're at risk of losing our identity," laments one old-school Chianti producer who asked not to be named, his voice tinged with nostalgia. "Not every wine needs to taste like it could be from Napa or Bordeaux. There's beauty in our traditional wines too."
It's a valid concern, but one that the best Super Tuscan producers reject. They argue that their wines express a unique Tuscan terroir, even if the grape varieties are international.
Masseto could only come from this tiny hill in Bolgheri, the combination of soil, climate, and our winemaking creates something truly unique. This is Tuscan wine, through and through.
As for the future of Super Tuscans, opinions are divided. Some see warning signs in recent auction data showing price plateaus for even top wines. Others point to the concern of weaker demand in emerging markets like China.
What's clear is that Super Tuscans have earned their place in the pantheon of great wines. Whether they represent good value is a question each collector must answer for themselves. But there's no denying the impact these revolutionary wines have had on Tuscany, Italy, and the wider wine world.
As the sun sets over the Bolgheri vineyards, casting a golden glow on the cypress-lined lanes, Nicolò Incisa della Rocchetta reflects on Sassicaia's legacy. He stands in the same spot where we began our journey, the vineyard now bathed in the warm light of dusk.
"My father's dream was simply to make a great wine," he says, his voice soft with emotion. "I think he would be amazed to see what his vision has created. Not just a wine, but a whole new chapter in Tuscan history."
As night falls and the first stars appear above the vineyards, one can't help but wonder what the next chapter will bring for these remarkable wines that dared to defy tradition and, in doing so, reshaped an entire industry.
If you work within a wine business and need help, then please email our friendly team via admin@aisultana.com .
Try the AiSultana consumer application for free, please click the button to chat, see, and hear the wine world like never before.
Comments